Sour Grapes
Of course we're Fair and Balanced!


Israel's wall

This post, by Noam Chomsky, is the first really thought-provoking commentary I've seen or heard on this topic.

If the goal were security, Israel would have built the fence a few km inside its borders. It could then be a mile high, patrolled on both sides by the IDF, mined with nuclear weapons, utterly impenetrable. Perfect security....

The basic principle was explained to the Cabinet of the Labor Government 30 years ago by Moshe Dayan, perhaps the most sympathetic to the Palestinians among the Israeli leadership: we should tell the Palestinians in the territories that "You shall continue to live like dogs, and whoever wishes, may leave, and we shall see where this process will lead."

The occupation should be "permanent," he believed, in one or another form, and to the objection that Israel must consider its moral stand, he responded that "Ben-Gurion said that whoever approaches the Zionist problem from a moral aspect is not a Zionist."

I certainly don't know enough to evaluate these thoughts completely, but I always appreciate an idea that makes sense and raises good questions.

Blog home
Blog archives